This beautiful photo from Chris P's photostream on Flickr...hereThere is no doubt that the new NRM release of City of Truro is a spectacularly lovely model. I couldn't hand build one as good as that, and certainly not to that price. So it's rather tragic that the two stunning examples of the Bachmann model that I have seen didn't actually work. I'm sure that most of the locos sold by the NRM work well, after all, there's a proud "Q.A." sticker on the box, isn't there?
My father-in-law purchased one from the NRM recently. After we had stood around in amazement, gazing at the wondrous thing, he put it on the layout, expecting the loco to move silkily away. Sadly, it stuttered ominously, buzzed and suddenly moved off, only to stop a few centimetres later. I should say that Bill has a sizeable stud of Bachmann locos that all run beautifully, so it's not his controller, or his track. After a couple of hours of running in on the rolling road, things were worse. So he contacted the NRM, who were very apologetic, offering him a full refund. However, Bill is 81, and is a little impatient, so he immediately ordered another one. He couldn't wait while the first one was returned and refunded.
The NRM did indeed send another immediately- top service. But this one was even worse, running in a series of scary lunges and refusing to work well enough even to "run in". So, the old boy has given up any thought of having the City of Truro, and has decided to wait for the promised "Castle" to be released. I just hope that runs properly...and that he lives long enough to see it.
But, back to the "City". I am sure there must be examples of this superb model out there that run well, I guess Bill has been unlucky. The NRM have been fine, doing all that could be asked of them. But what about that "Q.A." sticker? It's less than worthless.
4 comments:
Bachmann quality control has always been a little variable, but from this point? Then this is just appalling. Why are we expected to just take what we are given without any proper checking system?
Thanks, CF. Yes, I thought they had got over those problems, but apparently not. The old boy was so excited about getting the loco... and he was so disappointed. Hopefully the Hornby Castle will be a better runner!
Sounds like he was very unluck. I had the chance to test a City recently and it was fine on a Duette:http://philsworkbench.blogspot.com/2010/02/city-of-truro.html
I do wonder about the checking. Perhaps this is what happens when modellers start to buy based on cost - things get skipped. Of course if they are then the stick shouldn't be on the pack but you wonder what they check. Parhaps just that everything is in the box ?
I agree that I couldn't built a model of this quality (running aside) for the price ! Now when it coems out in BR Mixed traffic livery then I could be tempted...
Thanks for that, Phil. I read your blog post and I am very glad that the one you got to try worked perfectly! Bill must have just been unlucky.
I only saw Truro for the first time at Carrog last year, and it was love at first sight...I still think the model is superb...I think I would have kept it and just looked at it sitting there!
Post a Comment